[fuser]

talked to panini today and they are sending me 4 replacements cards that i was tired of waiting for. has been a little over a year now on them. the replacements were at their discression.on the ellard they said they have only sent out 2 of the 10 and the other 8 seem to be lost somewhere.how do you think i did?


#1-
Received:
01/03/2011 11:09 PM
2010 Certified Freshman Fabric#280 ( / 599)Dexter McCluster

Replaced:
01/20/2012 11:52 AM
2011 Threads Rookie #269 (129 / 400)Ryan Williams

#2-
Received:
01/18/2011 12:01 PM
2010 Certified Freshman Fabric#280 ( / 599)Dexter McCluster

Replaced:
01/20/2012 11:49 AM
2011 Threads
Rookie Collection Signature Materials#13 (13 / 25)Greg Little

#3-
Received:
01/03/2011 11:05 PM
2010 Rookies and Stars
Rookies Holofoil Signatures#246 ( / 299)Trent Williams

Replaced:
01/20/2012 11:56 AM
2010 Rookies and Stars
Dress for Success Jerseys Signatures#21 (60 / 100)Mardy Gilyard


#4-
Received:
01/18/2011 12:03 PM
2010 Certified
Fabric of the Game Jersey Number Prime Signatures#64 ( / 10)Henry Ellard

Replaced:
01/20/2012 11:31 AM
2008 Classics
Sunday's Best Jerseys Prime Signatures#31 (3 / 5)Ryan Grant

[tndcollectables]

Honest opinion, I think you got hosed.

[fuser]

yea, not what i was hoping for. told hime vikings/bears/lions and didnt get any of them

[ejiminee]

I've been waiting for 16 months for a redemption.

Contacted them after 5 months and they said "we're waiting to get the signed items..."

Cantacted them again a couple of months ago and got no reply.

I'm gettin' ticked, but I'm a little afraid of what I'll get if I tell them to just send me something.

[fuser]

yea, their replacements leave something to be desired. maybe i will be able to do something with the grant

[FrankMcdee]

I had a V. Shiancoe auto xx/5 redemption.. I called them and the person was nice.. got a certified Shady McCoy auto blue with like 3 pieces of gu on it... xx/25 thought I made out like a bandit

[fuser]

you did well, but for me i wasnt expecting anything great just thought the ellard would have gotten a better replacement. atleast another retired or hof'r

[fuser]

update-
i will give them props as the replacements came today in the mail

[tndcollectables]

did they at least look better? like a multicolor patch or anything?

[fuser]

here are scans.

[leedawg62]

They have been hosing a lot of people on replacements. I'm not sure it would be possible, but I'd love to get collectors together and file a class action lawsuit on the redemptions. I still have lots outstanding and its been almost a year.

[cornwellfamily]

I got hosed on a redemption card also. I pulled a Maroney auto jersey card numbered to 5 redemption that was actually booking for 150 at the time and ended up getting a wide receiver for San Francisco that did'nt ever make the playing field.

[barnsz]

Dude
Sorry about that

[fuser]

dude, make your own thread to buy stuff instead of spamming mine

[leedawg62]

Originally Posted by fuser

dude, make your own thread to buy stuff instead of spamming mine

Sent a PM to them.

Leland

[Brads55]

Sorry to hear you're not happy with the replacements (I wouldn't had been either). I, however, lucked out. I sent in for a Topps Reggie Jackson Auto /50 back October 2010. I was just about to contact Topps around Thanksgiving to request a replacement for it. I decided to wait on it. Low and behold I received it a couple weeks ago. Really stoked I didn't request the replacement.

[fuser]

i still have several i am waiting on and will continue to wait for a few of them. just not very happy with the way they go about it. they ask you what you like and then send nothing from the teams you ask for