Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

2011 Tna Signature 2 Box Break Review Contest

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 2011 Tna Signature 2 Box Break Review Contest

    Review is first followed by contest info


    2011 Tristar TNA Signature Impact Wrestling cards

    99 card base set with the last nine being sp's. Each box has either Sting, Flair, or Hogan and whoever is on the box is who you will get an sp of, and there are a total of 3 sp's each.

    A total print run of 90 cases.

    24 boxes per master case and 12 boxes per half case.

    6 cards per pack and 20 packs per box.

    Every case will include a Hulk Hogan auto and either a Rick Flair or Sting auto.

    7 hits per box and the breakdown follows as-
    3 autograph cards, one of which will be a multi-sig card numbered to 99 or less.
    1 event used numbered to 199 or less.
    2 base set parallels numbered to 50 or less.

    What was pulled




    Flair Box 725/2160-

    Few cards shy of a base set not counting the SP's.

    Rick Flair SP


    Mr. Anderson and Tara parallels both #d /50


    RVD and Kendrick autographs both #d /99


    Christy Hemme and SoCal Val dual autograph #d /99


    Mexican America quad event used #d /199



    Sting Box 1442/2160-

    Few cards shy of a base set not counting the SP's.

    Sting SP


    Hardy Boys and Scott Steiner parallels both #d /50


    SoCal Val and Samoa Joe autographs both #d /99


    Christy Hemme and SoCal Val dual autograph #d /99


    Mexican America quad event used #d 2/5



    Thoughts-

    Its safe to say that Tristar does it best to listen to collectors and attempt to put out a set that attempts to make all fans happy. As hard as they may try, it will never happen but the fact that they do says they care about the product they put out.

    Ive always dug their base sets until now. With the blue border scheme, it lacks and seems too plain for me. I find this to be a step back but at the sametime, I think they still did a fine job in what images were used on the cards.

    Something else I didnt care for in the base set was the "Impact Debut" cards. Bully Ray, Christy Hemme, and Anarquia just as a few. Theyve been on TNA before, granted it seems to be a show name change but I dont think that really makes it a "debut". As a collector a debut is their very first time on that brands trading card or show period.

    Even though I dont care for the base set design, I do like it with the event used and autograph cards.

    I like the event used a little more this go around vs. past releases. Since Icons with the Hogan letter swatch, theyve continued it here with Rick Flair. Its a nice change of pace to mix it up a little compared to the rest of the event used cards. I also like the "Impact Size" swatch cards as well.

    The fact that there are fewer single event used cards makes this a better release for me because alot of those can be left by the wayside when people crack a ton of boxes. The dual Hardy is a nice snag if you can get it along with the 2 different triples and 2 different quads, the talent used on those cards make ALOT of sense and I hope they continue that with future releases.

    At this time I have yet to see a Hogan or Flair autograph event used card. Im sure they are tough hits and will fetch a pretty penny on the secondary market.

    Back on to the autograph cards, to me this is probably one of the most complete lineups available. Even though the last two sets didnt include ODB, I understand why she miss the cut and I think I can forgive them for that.

    As mentioned previously, I didnt care for the new design with the base cards but I think it works really well with the autographs. Speaking for myself I say this is the 2nd nicest design on the autograph cards behind New Era. I would throw TNA Knockouts into the mix but it would be a little unfair not having any of the male talent having any autographs but being strictly ladies, that was a nice one too.

    Overall thoughts on this release are tough. With the increase in hits per box brings an increase on price for the collectors. You either have to buy several boxes and hope you dont get duplicate SP cards or you try to buy them. With 9 total, it could be expensive or hopefully you find them on the cheap from a casebreaker or two.

    Even though they were two random boxes numbered far apart, its a tough pill to swallow for collectors to have their 2 "bigger" hits be the same card. Im vaguely familiar with the packing out process but Id like to see better quality control with this if possible. I can honestly say I would make the same remarks if they were one of the 7 or 8 signed cards or even used autographs etc etc. Sure, those people would be happier but to have those two almost identical hits happen like that could upset collectors, especially if they had been lesser famous talent.

    As mentioned in previous thoughts and reviews on TNA products, Id like to see the print plates make a comeback, as well as redemptions for premium items like Cross the Line and New Era had.

    Overall I have to say if you are a TNA fan, this is a set you should try to break a box or two if you can afford it. If not, snag what you can on various trading sites. Its tough to give collectors what they want and keep costs down as much as possible, especially in this economy, but I think Tristar still does a better job with TNA than Topps does with the WWE.

    Contest Portion-

    Part 1. Guess the serial numbers. Over or under, it doesnt matter. The only one I outed was the quad event used #d /5. Attempt a guess on every card, all 4 parallels, the 1 event used, and all 6 of the autographs. Since this is done on more than one site, if you guess the same number on one site, that someone guessed on another site, whoever guessed first gets priority.

    Part 2. Give your opinion on the review and where you think they could improve and what you would like to see done with future releases.

    You MUST include #1 and #2 with your answers. Put some effort into it please! If the opinion portion is good enough, its entirely possible I can get some more prize material in the mix.

    This will be open for at least 1 wk. Depending on the action its getting in guessing and replies, I may hold it over longer.

    Edited answers are voided, if you forget a guess sorry, make it count.

    Since this will be posted on more than one site, theres a chance they may take an issue with it and delete it and tell me no! This isnt intended to promote any one site on others etc etc. If anyone has questions, dont hesitate to drop me a pm in order to keep the guessing portion of the thread clean and free of clutter.

    If you find this on another site, feel free to make different serial number guesses.

    I will be giving away most if not all of the hits, I may keep a dual for myself and the quad /5 for trading purposes *cough*ODB*cough*. Ill also have five sets of 5 card TNA obak cards from the 2011 Nattys as well as a TNA XL shirt. On top of that I still have some hits from past releases Ill be giving away from New Era to Icons and Xtreme.

    Hopefully I covered all the bases, if I have to edit anything, Ill note it at the end of the OP.

    Have at it!
    If my replies are slow, drop a pm!

    Stuff for trade-
    http://s5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...g%20Bye%20Bye/

  • #2
    What are the odds that you would pull the same dual Auto and Quad Relic/Patch of the same exact people? haha that's nuts. They have some nice looking cards though.

    My guess is #7/xx for all the cards.
    Bucket l Los Angeles Inspiration l Tradelist
    Collecting GU/Patches/Autos:
    Dodgers, UCLA, Mexico, Adrian Gonzalez, Magic Johnson, Kobe Bryant,
    Joe Johnson, Toney Douglas, Tony Gonzalez, Matt Ryan



    Comment


    • #3
      Wierd conicidence that you got both a Hemme/Val Dual Auto and the Mexican America Quad Relic in both boxes. Congrats on the pulls and nice review. I have liked the past few Tristar TNA products. It seems every new release gets better in my opinion. I like the look of the base cards. The Auto Cards look good with the silver glitter on it.

      Thanks for the contest. I will take a guess on each of the hit cards. Thanks again Will.

      Mr. Anderson Parallel - #36/50
      Tara Parallel - #14/50
      RVD Auto - #76/99
      Kendrick Auto - #84/99
      1st Box Hemme/Val Dual Auto - #28/99
      Mexican America Quad Relic #128/199

      Hardy Boys Parallel - #20/50
      Scott Steiner Parallel - #32/50
      SoCal Val Auto - #46/99
      Samoa Joe Auto - #58/99
      2nd Box Hemme/Val Dual Auto #72/99

      Comment


      • #4
        Mr. Anderson Parallel - 33
        Tara Parallel - #33
        RVD Auto - #33
        Kendrick Auto - #33
        1st Box Hemme/Val Dual Auto - #33
        Mexican America Quad Relic #133

        Hardy Boys Parallel - #33
        Scott Steiner Parallel - #33
        SoCal Val Auto - #33
        Samoa Joe Auto - #33
        2nd Box Hemme/Val Dual Auto #33

        Thanks so much for the contest!!!
        Part 2
        I really like the look of the cards. The action in the cards really make them a lot of fun. I think they could be a bit better if they all didn't seem to have a black background. Also, I'd like the idea of a famous matches, or jerseys from famous matches where it would mention a championship match where they wore that jersey. That would be really cool. I would also really like to see big mask cards which would have a cool swatch of a mask of a masked wrestler. Any big swatch card would really be nice to have also. I also would like to see a Then and Now type of card. I do like the autographs and jerseys in these boxes, so I'm not complaining, I just think those other things would be fun too!

        Thanks for the great contest!!!!

        Comment


        • #5
          36hrs from this reply the contest is over.
          If my replies are slow, drop a pm!

          Stuff for trade-
          http://s5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...g%20Bye%20Bye/

          Comment


          • #6
            Mr. Anderson Parallel - #16/50
            Tara Parallel - #25/50
            RVD Auto - #14/99
            Kendrick Auto - #53/99
            1st Box Hemme/Val Dual Auto - #22/99
            Mexican America Quad Relic #90/199

            Hardy Boys Parallel - #18/50
            Scott Steiner Parallel - #33/50
            SoCal Val Auto - #88/99
            Samoa Joe Auto - #80/99
            2nd Box Hemme/Val Dual Auto #78/99

            As for the 2nd part of the contest,

            I tend to agree that the blue was probably not the best color to choose as far as the border color. I personally wouldn't be opposed to either a simple white border, or even a borderless card akin to say the old Mother's Cookies Baseball cards from back in the 1980's. To me to do something like that once every few years makes it special instead of doing the same thing year after year.

            I would kill the short printed cards from the regularly numbered set. I understand the thought process from a business/sales perspective for doing it that way, but the reality is it kills the value of the base cards even further and drives set collectors nuts. I would rather them just make those cards some kind of insert set and be done with it.

            I feel that TriStar and TNA do a good job of having one of the most complete line ups when it comes to the autographs. It is possible to get practically everyone on the TNA Roster including refs, announcers, etc I like the multi signed autographs as well. I still feel that there are way too many parallels in the TriStar product. It makes little to no sense to me to have 4 and 5 levels of a stickered autograph product of the same card with just a different color foil. If they are going to continue with the parallels, do something different like a different picture or even picture placement on the card, something that sets it apart more then just the color of foil.

            The Multi Relic cards are pretty cool. The 2nd Mex/Amer card really pops because of the multiple colors.

            Overall, a real nice product from what I've seen.

            Comment


            • #7
              Had some family come into town. Will get to this tonight or tomorrow.
              If my replies are slow, drop a pm!

              Stuff for trade-
              http://s5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...g%20Bye%20Bye/

              Comment


              • #8
                tara 9/50
                mr anderson 50/50
                quad 119/199
                kendrick 23/99
                rvd 25/99
                dual 81/99

                hardy boys 23/50
                steiner 2/50

                joe 29/99
                val 89/99
                dual 45/99

                The only card guessed right was the Hardy Boys and out of the 3 people to guess it, the member from SCF was the first to answer.
                If my replies are slow, drop a pm!

                Stuff for trade-
                http://s5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...g%20Bye%20Bye/

                Comment

                Working...
                X