Coghlan & Bailey are R.O.Y.

[JesRey]

http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=4660425

The Marlins Left Fielder Chris Coghlan & Oakland Athletics Closer Andrew Bailey

[Brads55]

That's right! Bailey's a P-I-M-P!

[JesRey]

Brett Anderson should have won it, if they were going to give it to an Athletic lol

[gladdyontherise]

Bailey didnt deserve it in my opinion, Porcello much more deserving

Coghlan was a shoe in though, only because Happ dropped off at the end of the year

[JesRey]

Bailey didnt deserve it in my opinion, Porcello much more deserving

Coghlan was a shoe in though, only because Happ dropped off at the end of the year

i'm assuming you dont watch baseball..

It came down to Coghlan and MucCutchen, and i thought McCutchen should have won

[gladdyontherise]

I do watch baseball JA Happ = ROY deserving

12-4 2.93 ERA 119 KOs and in only 23 starts, imagine if he got 32-36, he'd of easily won another 5-8 games

[JesRey]

Well he didnt so you can't give it to Happ

It's rookie of the year, not rookie of half the year

[gladdyontherise]

Have played most the year, he played the best, and was most deserving, pitchers always get snubbed when theres someone half way decent at a fielding position

[Mister_Ed]

unfortunately, ROY isnt looked at like MVP- ROY is almost purely stats, whereas MVP is also how they helped their team. I like Porcello over Bailey, and Happ over Coghlan also, although Id have put McCutchen above Coghlan as well. Straight stats wise- the two that won probably were the best, but if they changed the qualifications a bit, then it would have been Happ (maybe McCutchen) before Coghlan, and Porcello ahead of bailey i na tight race

Holy cow Dan, we actually agree on something...

[gladdyontherise]

The AL was much more wide open, you could've said Romero until about the last month, Porcello had a MONSTER September though, i thought being in a pennant race vs being completely out of it since the begining of the year meant something, boy was i wrong

[pistonsfan9826]

i thought that mccutchen should have won it in the nl and in the al rick porcello or gordon beckham. i had no idea who bailey was till i looked him up on google.