Who Would You Rather Have On Your MLB Team?

[key2win]

2 standout outfielders who were All Stars in their rookie seasons. Which one would you rather have on your MLB team if you were going to build the franchise around this player?

Mike Trout or Bryce Harper?

Obviously it is biased for me since Angels are my team and I live 20 minutes from Angels Stadium.

[ocanseco55]

Trout! At this stage he is the better player!

[gladdyontherise]

Still gonna say Harper. What he's doing at 19 hasn't been done very often, i'd expect him to break out more next year. Don't think there is a wrong answer though.

[OriolesFan]

Personally, I'd wait a year or two before I'd decide what player(s) I'd build my franchise/team around. Both of these guys are doing good, especially Trout. However, there have been many players in MLB history who have had good rookie seasons and then faded out, never to have good/great seasons again. But both Trout and Harper are both having a good/great impact with their teams during their "rookie" year.

[jwgreen68]

I think Trout is the better player. Trout is humble whereas Harper is still cocky.....I thought the Cole Hamel Welcoming Committee would have taken him down a notch or two but he seemed to still find a way to get under Ozzie Guillen's skin!

Trout has proven he's ready and should be in the big leagues but I think Harper could use at least another year of 10 hour bus rides.

[ocanseco55]

Still gonna say Harper. What he's doing at 19 hasn't been done very often, i'd expect him to break out more next year. Don't think there is a wrong answer though.

I totally agree I think they will be on equal footing once Harper has anoth year under his belt!

[bakemeister52]

Trout is the better one right now and Harper will get better with age!