Who Has Been The Best First Baseman In The Last 15 Years?

[key2win]

Who do you think has been the best first baseman in the last 15 years? I am only naming players who played from 1995 to 2010.

[jsab4807]

I went with Thome. Pujols is the obvious choice, but Thome has been very productive over almost all 15 years mentioned, while Pujols didn't come into the league until about halfway through the time-frame mentioned.

[JesRey]

Pujols has done so much already and he's still in his prime right now. His numbers are ridiculous and already has a ring.

[B.I.G.Poppa]

Pujols. Ridiculously talented. Like Jesse said, he already has staggering nembers and a ring, and he's still in his prime.

[gladdyontherise]

Pujols, Thome is a homer pick

[jsab4807]

Pujols, Thome is a homer pick

Not at all. This is the last 15 years, not the last 8 years. That's why I went with Thome.

[JesRey]

Not at all. This is the last 15 years, not the last 8 years. That's why I went with Thome.

But this is Pujols 10th year

[jsab4807]

But this is Pujols 10th year

8, 10, close enough.

[key2win]

If this was from 1990 to 2000, I would have voted for Frank Thomas. He was amazing every single season until he got injured.

I voted for Albert Pujols on this one.

[Myerburg311]

It's gotta be Pujols.. Thome hasn't even played first regularly since 04.. so he was basically a 1B from 97-05