What would you rather have???

[Dacubs?]

I know bv wise, they are different and I'll list the bv's after a day or two, so you are not influenced by them...but which of the 3 cards would you rather have??

2009 UD Exquisite Chris Johnson Biography Auto Triple GU #/50

2009 UD SP Authentic Michael Crabtree Super Patch Auto #/99

2009 Philadelphia Peyton Manning On-Card Auto

[gladdyontherise]

I'd assume the Manning is a SP so i'd probably rather have that one.

[B.I.G.Poppa]

The Manning honestly. I don't really care about limited #ing or jersey pieces in the card, i'd rather have an auto of one of the greatest QBs of all time.

[ranbethscards]

I have to ask...is the Johnson multi-colored? Patch? that would make a big difference in my opinion.

[Brads55]

I'd go with the Manning.

[Dacubs?]

I have to ask...is the Johnson multi-colored? Patch? that would make a big difference in my opinion.

probably all 3 single color jersey

[ranbethscards]

probably all 3 single color jersey

still.....it's something different...I'll go with it.

[jsab4807]

The Peyton. He's one of the best QB's to ever play the game....it'd be a no-brainer for me.

[OriolesFan]

Without a doubt I'd go with the PEYTON MANNING - Who are those other guys?????? Even without following football I STILL know who Manning is.

[dx2010]

Id go with cj2k

[Dacubs?]

well...heres the story....

2 people redeemed the redemption for the Chris Johnson card bv=100 and asked for a replacement...

Both people listed Peyton Manning as a possible replacement choice...

One got the Crabtree as a replacement bv=150

the other got the Manning bv=80

[B.I.G.Poppa]

I believe you were the one that got the Crabby. Are you happy with it, or do you prefer the Manning? Obviuously you came out on top BV wise, but bv pales in comparison to personal value.

[key2win]

I dont know anything about football, but I would say this one because its an Exquisite card and an auto jersey too

2009 UD Exquisite Chris Johnson Biography Auto Triple GU #/50

[ejiminee]

The Manning would be my choice, simply because of his record. He's proven that he is a great player, year after year. The others haven't done that, yet.

[Dacubs?]

I believe you were the one that got the Crabby. Are you happy with it, or do you prefer the Manning? Obviuously you came out on top BV wise, but bv pales in comparison to personal value.

I am the one with the crabby...I think I'm just more bummed about not getting a manning auto (even if it is lower bv)...you gotta wonder who at Upper Deck in replacements dept decides who gets what

probably doesn't help that I already had the crabby