Who get's the best deal? Fantasy trade

[Sports Collector]

It's a three way trade that we kind of talked about earlier but I made a few changes

#1 gets: Visanthe Shancoe, Wes Welker
#2 gets: Desean Jackson, Chester Taylor
#3 gets: Antonio Gates, Matt Shaub

Pretty much everybody get's there needs met, but is it a fair trade for everyone and please rank who get's the best deal 1-3

Thanks

[jsab4807]

#3 is making out like a bandit.....then #2, then #1. #2 and #1 get reversed if it's a PPR league.

[Sports Collector]

The sad thing is that #3 is going to be the one to complain because he is giving up Welker lol

#1 is giving up Desean Jackson and Chester Taylor
#2 is giving up Gates and Shaub
#3 is giving up Shancoe and Welker

what is ppr?

[jsab4807]

Points per reception.

[JesRey]

I say #3 got the best, then #1 and #2 is last for me

[Sports Collector]

Well, I'm #1...basically #2 is out of the playoffs and #3 thinks he has a chance when he really doesn't...

I have a first round bye and my only weakness is te (hence why I need Shancoe/gates)

I might just do D.Jackson for Gates but then I have a big hole in my wr production...that's why I need Welker

I don't mind giving up Chester Taylor at all...I don't think I've played him at all...

[JesRey]

What kind of league still allows trades right now? It should have passed a long time ago

[Sports Collector]

The guy meant to make it today, but he made a mistake and made it in a week

[jsab4807]

What kind of league still allows trades right now? It should have passed a long time ago

I was gonna ask the same thing....my trade deadlines were all at the end of November, lol.

[JesRey]

meant to make it today??? It's Week 15 already.

Week 9... maybe 10 at the most

[Sports Collector]

I was gonna ask the same thing....my trade deadlines were all at the end of November, lol.

meant to make it today??? It's Week 15 already.

Week 9... maybe 10 at the most

I guess he wanted to allow trades right up until the playoffs?

They start this week...

anyways that's off topic

you've seen what I'm giving up and what I'm getting, do you think it's a good deal for me?

[shapingle]

see if you can give chester taylor for a deisant te like shiancoe. i say keep welker.

[pistonsfan9826]

i think its oj, not the best though.